Effective May 21, 2023, P&N has joined EisnerAmper. Read the full announcement here.
Did you know that creating or having a transaction with a foreign trust may result in U.S. income tax consequences and/or information reporting requirements? A U.S. person's failure to observe these rules can lead to significant penalties and an extended time for the IRS to assess any tax imposed for a relevant period.
The tax consequences can apply to U.S. persons treated as owners of a foreign trust and U.S. persons treated as beneficiaries of a foreign trust and to the foreign trust itself. So, it is essential to understand your relationship to any trust you believe is a foreign trust.
The IRS defines U.S. person to include the following:
Do you have a trust? Clients often have complex legal agreements where the creation of a trust is evident. In other situations, the existence of a trust may not be that clear. A taxpayer may have a trust when the following four factors have been satisfied:
Once you have determined that you have a trust, the question becomes whether the trust is domestic or foreign. A trust will be considered foreign when it does not meet both the "control test" and "court test." A trust that meets just one of the tests will be viewed as a domestic trust and taxed appropriately under the U.S. income tax laws.
The control test seeks to determine if any U.S. persons can control the material decisions of the trust. Specifically, the control test will be satisfied if a U.S. person(s) has the authority to control all substantial decisions of the trust without any other entity having the power to veto said decisions. A substantial decision is any decision that a person is required/authorized to make under the trust arrangement.
If your trust does not meet the control test, you can proceed to analyze whether it fails or satisfies the court test. The court test may be satisfied when a U.S. court has jurisdiction over a trust to resolve all issues regarding the administration duties (whether prescribed by law or the trust documents).
U.S. Treasury regulations attempt to provide further guidance by stating that the court test will be satisfied under any of the following circumstances:
Failure to understand these regulations can create situations where a trust meant to be foreign is classified as a domestic trust. To prevent the misclassification of a trust, the regulations provide for an "automatic migration clause" and a "safe harbor rule" so taxpayers can have clarity in planning.
The automatic migration clause clarifies that the court test will not be satisfied when the trust instrument states that any attempt by a U.S. court to assert jurisdiction would cause the trust to migrate from the U.S.
Under the safe harbor rule, a trust without an automatic migration clause will satisfy the court test if the administration of the trust is exclusively in the U.S. and there is no provision in the trust's instrument allowing for its administration elsewhere. Careful planning and execution are required if a U.S. person aims to establish a foreign trust.
The next question in determining the U.S. tax impacts is whether the foreign trust is considered a grantor trust for U.S. tax purposes.
When the grantor (person funding the trust) is a U.S. person, a grantor trust may exist where the grantor retains powers over the distribution of income:
The possibility of applying income in satisfaction of the grantor's obligation of support of a beneficiary other than the spouse isn't enough to create a grantor trust. Only income applied to or distributed in the discharge of the grantor's legal obligation of support will make the trust a grantor trust.
When the grantor is a foreign person, a grantor trust may exist where:
For U.S. income tax purposes, a foreign grantor owns all income generated by the foreign grantor trust. However, only the income generated from U.S. sources may be taxed by the U.S. government. Any income earned from sources outside of the U.S. may escape U.S. taxation. This fact creates a great U.S. tax planning opportunity.
The idea is that a foreign grantor can establish a foreign grantor trust for U.S. beneficiaries and may be able to accumulate earnings free from U.S. taxation by investing the corpus outside the U.S. The earnings may then be distributed tax-free to U.S. beneficiaries.
The U.S. grantor of a foreign grantor trust may be taxed on all the trust income earned worldwide. The distributions from the trust may be made tax-free to any U.S. beneficiaries. Special rules prevent a U.S. grantor from establishing a foreign non-grantor trust to shield income from U.S. income taxation. The potential foreign non-grantor trust will automatically become a foreign grantor trust if it could distribute any of the income or corpus to U.S. persons in the future. In addition, if the trust acquires a U.S. beneficiary within five years of creation, the U.S. grantor could be taxed immediately on all undistributed income from the prior tax years. Thus, establishing foreign trusts requires careful planning where the goal is to benefit non-U.S. beneficiaries.
A foreign non-grantor trust may only be subject to U.S. taxation on income derived from U.S. sources. The income is not taxed on the U.S. returns of any foreign or U.S. grantor. The U.S. beneficiaries may be taxed on distributions received from foreign non-grantor trusts.
A complex set of rules governs this taxation, including the following stipulations:
In addition to filing U.S. income tax returns, U.S. beneficiaries, U.S. grantors, and trustees may be required to file the following informational returns:
Keep the above information and reporting requirements in mind when conducting transactions with a foreign trust. Contact your P&N tax advisor to learn more about strategies to minimize your U.S. income tax obligations.